学术论文的发表过程和投稿技巧

第四章 学术论文的发表过程和

投稿技巧

§4.1评审与出版

§4.2 稿件投递

§4.3 论文发表

§4.4 版权转让

§4.5 与编辑、审稿专家沟通

一位国际主编对中国学术论文的印象

“A great deal of excellent research is submitted from China.”

“I have encountered the following serious

issues on an occasional basis (but more often than I would like)…”

Multiple submission of the same manuscript to two or

more journals

Submission of a paper already published in Chinese

Plagiarism (especially of small parts of a paper)

– Paul Haddad, Editor, Journal of Chromatography A

“The following problems appear much too frequently”

Submission of papers which are clearly out of scope Failure to format the paper according to the Guide for Authors

Inappropriate (or no) suggested reviewers

Inadequate response to reviewers

Inadequate standard of English

Resubmission of rejected manuscripts without

revision

– Paul Haddad, Editor, Journal of Chromatography A

出版机构的忠告

Submit to the right journal (scope and prestige) Submit to one journal only

Do not submit “salami” article

Pay attention to journal requirements

Pay attention to structure

Check the English

Pay attention to ethical standards

稿件处理过程

START

Reviewer Editor

Author

Submit a paper

Assign

reviewers Collect reviewers’recommendations Review and give recommendation

Revise the paper

Basic requirements met?

[Yes]

[No]

Make a

decision

[Reject]

[Accept] REJECT

ACCEPT [Revision required]

Reviewer

Editor

Author ACCEPT 论文发表过程

PUBICATION

Prepare Final

Manuscript

Submit to Publisher

[Proof]

§4.1 评审与出版

Journal Publications

A journal paper reports on a finished piece of research or some significant achievement or discovery in a certain scientific field. Unlike at conferences, it is uncommon that international journals accept reports on research in progress at an early stage.

----Michael Derntl, University of Vienna.

Basics of Research Paper Writing and Publishing

Referee（编委＋外审专家）

编委：A journal has an editorial board that includes a number of referees who are responsible for reviewing and evaluating submitted papers. Having reviewed a paper, each referee independently advises the editor whether to accept or to reject the paper. Referees may also advise the editor on the development of the journal's thematic scope and focus. However, final decisions are made by the editor.

外审专家：It is also common practice that editors designate external referees for certain submissions, for example when the referees of the editorial board do not have appropriate expertise to make fruitful, professional comments on a particular paper.