love-is-a-fallacy(英语修辞与写作-lecture-6-1)
love-is-a-fallacy(英语修辞与写作-lecture-6-1)PPT课件
8. A society is free if and only if liberty is maximized and people are required to take responsibility for their actions.
10. Understatement (It must not be thought
that I was without lo.ve for this girl.)
6
Logical fallacies in the story
▪ Dicto Simpliciter ▪ Hasty generalization ▪ Post hoc ▪ Contradictory premises ▪ Ad Misericordiam (Appeal to pity) ▪ False analogy ▪ Hypothesis contrary to fact ▪ Poisoning the well (Ad Hominem)
9. Analogy (It was like digging a tunnel. At first, everything was work, sweat, and darkness. … But I persisted. I pounded and clawed and scraped, and finally I was rewarded. I saw a chink of light. And then the chink got bigger and the sun came pouring in and all was bright.)
高级英语课件-Love-is-a-Fallacy
Detailed Study of the Text
Ⅱ. Background Information
Explanation of thelogical Fallacies A logical argument gives evidence to
support some conclusion.
two necessary parts:
a conclusion the thesis argues for certain premises or facts on which to base
the conclusion
The conclusion is to be inferred from the premises.
Ⅲ. Learning Focus
Structure of the Narration
1. The protagonist: Dobie Gillis--- a self conceited freshman
2. The antagonist: Petey Burch--- his stupid roommate Polly Espy--- the beautiful dumb girl
4) False Analogy
“It doe not follow” arises when there is not even a deceptively plausible appearance of valid reasoning, because the given premises have virtually nothing to do with the conclusion drawn from them.
love is a fallacy
John Ruskin -- (1819-1900)
English critic and social theorist • a writer on art and architecture • In his later writings he attacked social and economic problems • Modern Painters • The Stones of Venice • The Seven Lamps of Architecture • Time and Tide
• Charles Lamb, as merry and enterprising a fellow as… Old china and Dream’s Children (para.1)
paraphrase:Charles Lamb is an unusual guy full of merry spirit, energy and initiative, who sets free the informal essay by his two essays Old China and Dream’s Children unfetter-- set free/let sth go freely / be completely out of control unfetter the productive forces 解放生产力 A month of sundays:(colloquial) a long time.
L/O/G/O
love is a fallacy
By Max Shulman
李丽 0812010309
Detailed study of the text: • title -- humorous/ well chosen – 1. When "fallacy" is taken in its ordinary sense, the title means:
LoveisaFallacy解读
爱情就是谬误马克斯舒尔曼查尔斯．兰姆是一个世所罕见的性情欢快、富有进取心的人，他那笔下的散文《古瓷器》和《梦中的孩子》无拘无束、自由奔放。
实在令人难忘。
下面这篇文章比兰姆的作品更加自由奔放。
实际上，用“自由奔放”的字眼来形容这篇文章并不十分确切，或许用“柔软”、“轻松”或“轻软而富有弹性”更为恰如其分。
尽管很难说清这篇文章是属于哪一类，但可以肯定它是一篇散文小品文。
它提出了论点。
引用了许多例证，并得出了结论。
卡菜尔能写得更好吗?罗斯金呢?这篇文章意在论证逻辑学非但不枯燥乏味而且活泼、清新、富于关感和激情，并给人以启迪。
诸位不妨一读。
——作者注我这个人头脑冷静，逻辑思维能力强。
敏锐、慎重、聪慧、深刻、机智一一这些就是我的特点。
我的大脑像发电机一样发达，孳化学家的天平一样精确，像手术刀一样锋利。
一一你知道吗?我才十八岁呀。
年纪这么轻而智力又如此非凡的人并不常有。
就拿在明尼苏达大学跟我同住一个房间的皮蒂·伯奇来说吧，他跟我年龄相哆’经历一样，可他笨得像头驴。
小伙子长得年轻漂亮，可惜脑子里却空空如也。
他易于激动，情绪反复无常，容易受别人的影响。
最糟的是他爱赶时髦。
我认为，赶时髦就是最缺乏理智的表现。
见到一 q9种新鲜的东西就跟着学，以为别人都在那么干，自己也就卷进去傻干——这在我看来，简直愚蠢至极，但皮蒂却不以为然。
一天下午我看见皮蒂躺在床上，脸上显露出一种痛苦不堪的表情，我立刻断定他是得了阑尾炎。
“别动，”我说，“别吃泻药，我就请医生来。
”“浣熊，”他咕哝着说。
“浣熊?”我停下来问道。
“我要一件浣熊皮大衣，”他痛苦地哭叫着。
我明白了，他不是身体不舒服，而是精神上不太正常。
“你为什么要浣熊皮大衣?”“我本早该知道，”他哭叫着，用拳头捶打着太阳穴，“我早该知道查尔斯登舞再度流行时，浣熊皮大衣也会时兴起来的。
我真傻，钱都买了课本，可现在不能买浣熊皮大衣了。
”我带着怀疑的眼神问道：“你是说人们真的又要穿浣熊皮大衣吗?”“校园里有身分的人哪个不穿?你刚从哪儿来?”“图书馆，”我说了一个有身分的人不常去的地方。
Unit_5_Love_is_a_Fallacy爱是谬论 高英
Theme Song Lyrics Dobie, wants a little cutie,
Dobie, wants a little beauty, Dobie wants a gal to call his own
Any size, any style, any eyes, any smile, Any Jean, any Jane, any Joan.
"Dobie Gillis"
The moral of the story is "You can't always get what you want, but if you try some time, you just might find, you get what you need."
Cupid Zelda hits her target (Dobie)
Quotations from Dobie Gillis (1)
"My name is Dobie Gillis and I like girls. What am I saying? I love girls! Love 'em! Beautiful, gorgeous, soft, round, creamy girls. Now, I'm not a wolf, mind you. No, you see a wolf wants lots of girls, but me? Well, I just want one. One beautiful, gorgeous, soft, round, creamy girl for my very own. That's all I want! One lousy girl!""But I'll tell you a sad, hard fact. I'm never gonna get a girl. Never. Why? Because to get a girl you need money . And standing between me and money is a powerful obstacle: a POWERFUL obstacle!"
高级英语课件-Love-is-a-Fallacy讲课讲稿
Teaching Focus
piece of narrative writing.
The narrator of the story, Dobie Gillis, a self-conceited freshman in a school
struggles against Petey Burch, his stupid roommate whose girl friend he plans to steal and Polly Espy, the beautiful dumb girl he intends to marry after suitable
Teaching Methods
1. Teacher-oriented teaching method 2. Student-oriented teaching method 3. The elicited method
Teaching Procedure
Ⅰ. Introductory Remarks Ⅱ. Background Information Ⅲ. Learning Focus Ⅳ. Key words and Expressions Ⅴ. Explanation of the Text
Unit 4
Love Is a Fallacy
Max Shulman
Teaching Plan
Teaching Objectives
love is a fallacy一文中修辞手段的应用
love is a fallacy一文中修辞手段的应用美国著名的幽默作家Max Shu man的精彩之作Love is aFallcy;语句幽默,运用了多种修辞方法,充满讽刺意味,达到了很好的语言表现效果。
明喻：一种最常见的修辞方法,就是将具有某种共同特征的两种不同事物加以对比,用另一种事物比方所要说明的事物，使语言形象生动0Charles Lamb, as merry and enterprising a fellowv as you wa month of Sundaysmcet h ypineo sous ie poerhlas a dgnmo as prcie as a chenefs scales as penetrating as a scalpel 暗喻：隐喻要靠读者自己去意会的比喻。
隐喻没有指明两个不同事物共同点而是用一个具有形象意义的词来直接称谓代替)某个事物。
这情,更具表that logic, far fion being a dry pedantic discipline, is a living breath inth ing fill of beauty passion, and traumaMaybe somewhere in the extinct crater of her m ind a fwembers still smolded Maybe samehow I cou ld fan them into flamt借代：文章时不直接说出所要表达的人或事物,而是借用与它有密切相关的人或事物来代替,这种修辞方法叫借代。
恰当地运用代可以突出事物的本质特征,增强语言的形象性,而且可以使文笔简洁精炼,语言富于变化和幽默感移就：又称词语移用,就是有意识的把描写甲事物的词语移用来描写乙事物，是在特殊语言环境中改变词语搭配关系的一种临时迁用。
从语言逻辑上看,好像不合规范,也不合情理,但在具体的语言环境中,它却能赋予个词语以新的意义,增强语言的表达效0I said with mysterious wink and closed my bag and left” pa40Amyseriouswink 就是一个典型的移就的例子。
love is a fallacy 爱情是谬误上课讲义
l o v e i s a f a l l a c y 爱情是谬误在进入今天主题，讲述我和小美的故事之前我想先给大家推荐这样的一片文章，其实正是因为我自己的经历我才深深的懂得了这篇文章的内在，而我希望将它跟大家分享，如果你在爱情里面遇到类似的问题，那么我相信这篇文章会给你一点启示的，当然同时，你也可以提升自己的英文。
Love Is a Fallacy《爱情是个谬误》这是一篇我非常喜欢的文章，这也是在大学里我教授的三年级外语专业学生高级英语课本里面的一篇经典文章，国外的大学生也会同步在写作课学习这篇文章。
以前我喜欢它只是单纯把它当做一篇幽默的文章来对待，其实也没有深深的去体会过其中滋味，但是现在我才真正体会到为什么爱情是一个谬误。
主人公是一个非常自信甚至很自负的法学院大一男生Dobbie,他自认为又帅，又有才，他看上了自己室友的女友，很想得到那个女生，但是这个女生Polly只是一个表面很漂亮但却很没有脑子的女生，所以Dobbie决定要先改变这个女孩，把她变聪明之后再得到她。
当然第一步是得先得到室友的同意。
室友是一个拜金狂，依然没有脑子，于是Dobbie用一件浣熊大衣作为交换条件就轻松得到了室友的许可，于是就和Polly开始约会了。
约会的内容就是教不同的逻辑谬误给Polly，为的就是让她变聪明，因为主人公认为逻辑是让人变聪明的法宝，于是约会就这么开始了，他教授的逻辑问题如下：1. 绝对判断（Dicto Simpliciter）的谬误。
例子如下：“运动是非常有益的，它能增强体质，所以每个人都应该做运动!”，这个论断是明显错误的，因为运动有益是一种无条件的前提。
比方说，假设你得了心脏病，运动不但无益，反而有害，有不少人医生就不准他们运动。
你必须给这种前提加以限制。
你应该说，一般来说运动是有益的。
或者说，对大多数人是有益的。
否则就是犯了绝对判断的错误2. 草率结论（Hasty Generalization）的谬误。
love is a fallacy
Fred, the Australian, stole my wallet. Thus, all Australians are thieves.
Post Hoc 牵强附会
Eg. Immigration to Alberta from Ontario increased. Soon after,
False Analogy 错误类比
Eg. Employees are like nails. Just as nails must be hit in the head in order to make them work, so must employees. Surgeons have X-rays to guide them during an operation , lawyers have briefs to guide them during a trail , carpenters have blueprints to guide them when they are building a house. So students should be allowed to look at their textbooks during examinations.
Discussion
What is your understanding of true love? What do you think love is? Is love a fallacy, a mistake, an error?
What’s the meaning of love and happiness?
I was nauseous and tingly all
over. I was either in love or I had smallpox.
高级英语2love-is-a-fallacy中英译文
Cool was I and logical. Keen, calculating, perspicacious, acute and astute—I was all of these. My brain was as powerful as a dynamo, precise as a chemist’s scales, as penetrating as a scalpel. And—think of it!—I only eighteen.我这个人头脑冷静，逻辑思维实力强。
敏锐、慎重、聪慧、深刻、机灵一一这些就是我的特点。
我的大脑像发电机一样发达，像化学家的天平一样精确，像手术刀一样锐利。
一一你知道吗?我才十八岁呀。
It is not often that one so young has such a giant intellect. Take, for example, Pete y Bellows, my roommate at the university. Same age, same background, but dumb a s an ox. A nice enough fellow, you understand, but nothing upstairs. Emotional type. Unstable. Impressionable. Worst of all, a faddist. Fads, I submit, are the very negat ion of reason. To be swept up in every new craze that comes along, to surrender o neself to idiocy just because everybody else is doing it—this, to me, is the acme of mindlessness. Not, however, to Petey.年纪这么轻而智力又如此非凡的人并不常有。
love is a fallacy
Love is a FallacyAction 1The first day I went to university,I met Petey in the dormitory.He is a handsome and fashionable boy.He wore the latest most popular clothes. At that time I envied him very much. A term passed,he became more and more popular in our class.He was a faddist. A lot of classmates liked to stay with him to talk about fashion and always invited him to their parties.I was not interested in the fashion,because I was a keen,calculating,penetrating and cool boy.keen,calculating,penetrating and cool boy.I liked living alone.In my mind, there was no people can understand my idea and wisdom.One day,it was raining heavily after class,all of the classmates went to dormitories.I have no umbrella,so I had to stay in the classroom. I have no umbrella,so I had to stay in the classroom.I have no umbrella,so I had to stay in the classroom. A few minutes passed,suddenly I saw abeautiful and fashionable girl. She walked towards me and gave me an umbrella. Then she disappeared in the rain without any words. My heart was pounding when I saw her face.She was such a beautiful girl. I went to my dormitory.That night a beautiful scene always emerged in my mind.The second dayI went to classroomand saw her sit besides Petey and talk with him happily. She had so fascinating a face. At that second,I felt depressed without no reason. From then,I paid attention to her silently. I was waiting for a chance to take her. I hated Petey grabbing my stuff.Action 3Polly didn’t like me.From the beginning,she just wanted to give a lesson. Petey told her the whole truth.She hated my nosense of shame. At this time,I knew I was a really dumb.Petey played a trick on me. He wasthe last winner.He got a double harvest---Fashion and Polly.。
love-is-a-fallacy(英语修辞与写作-lecture-6-1)讲解学习
8. Antithesis (It is, after all, easier to make a beautiful dumb girl smart than to make an ugly smart girl beautiful.)
Rhetorical devices in the story
1. Inversion (Cool was I and logical. // Beautiful she was. Gracious she was. Intelligent she was not. )
2. Metaphor (My brain, that precision instrument, slipped into high gear.)
9. Analogy (It was like digging a tunnel. At first, everything was work, sweat, and darkness. … But I persisted. I pounded and clawed and scraped, and finally I was rewarded. I saw a chink of light. And then the chink got bigger and the sun came pouring in and all was bright.)
Writing Style
Max Shulman has a good style. The story goes forward at a fast pace with racy dialogues full of American colloquialism and slang. He employs a whole variety of writing techniques to make his story vivid. He use ultra learned terms to reveal the conceit of the narrator and clipped vulgar forms to illustrate Polly Espy’s limited intellectual capability. He also use figurative language profusely and inversion for emphasis. The speed of the narration is maintained by the use of short sentences, elliptical sentences and dashes throughout the story. The combination of all these help to make the story realistic, as one would expect a freshman to talk like that.
love-is-a-fallacy-爱情是谬误培训讲学
在进入今天主题，讲述我和小美的故事之前我想先给大家推荐这样的一片文章，其实正是因为我自己的经历我才深深的懂得了这篇文章的内在，而我希望将它跟大家分享，如果你在爱情里面遇到类似的问题，那么我相信这篇文章会给你一点启示的，当然同时，你也可以提升自己的英文。
Love Is a Fallacy《爱情是个谬误》这是一篇我非常喜欢的文章，这也是在大学里我教授的三年级外语专业学生高级英语课本里面的一篇经典文章，国外的大学生也会同步在写作课学习这篇文章。
以前我喜欢它只是单纯把它当做一篇幽默的文章来对待，其实也没有深深的去体会过其中滋味，但是现在我才真正体会到为什么爱情是一个谬误。
主人公是一个非常自信甚至很自负的法学院大一男生Dobbie,他自认为又帅，又有才，他看上了自己室友的女友，很想得到那个女生，但是这个女生Polly 只是一个表面很漂亮但却很没有脑子的女生，所以Dobbie决定要先改变这个女孩，把她变聪明之后再得到她。
当然第一步是得先得到室友的同意。
室友是一个拜金狂，依然没有脑子，于是Dobbie用一件浣熊大衣作为交换条件就轻松得到了室友的许可，于是就和Polly开始约会了。
约会的内容就是教不同的逻辑谬误给Polly，为的就是让她变聪明，因为主人公认为逻辑是让人变聪明的法宝，于是约会就这么开始了，他教授的逻辑问题如下：1. 绝对判断（Dicto Simpliciter）的谬误。
例子如下：“运动是非常有益的，它能增强体质，所以每个人都应该做运动!”，这个论断是明显错误的，因为运动有益是一种无条件的前提。
比方说，假设你得了心脏病，运动不但无益，反而有害，有不少人医生就不准他们运动。
你必须给这种前提加以限制。
你应该说，一般来说运动是有益的。
或者说，对大多数人是有益的。
否则就是犯了绝对判断的错误2. 草率结论（Hasty Generalization）的谬误。
例子如下：“你不会讲法语，我不会讲法语，皮蒂也不会讲法语。
高级英语第五课love_is_a_fallacy
Logical fallacy:逻辑谬论 逻辑论证，即提出支持某些论题或结论的论据。 论证有两个部分组成：论点所支持的结论，与引 证结论的某些前提。而结论是经由前提所推导出 来的。当前提为结论提供确凿证据时，论据的演 绎推理便有效；反之则会成为谬论。成为谬误的 方式有三种：a内容，即事实陈述错误；b措词， 即术语使用错误；c结构（或形式），即推导过程 错误。那么，逻辑谬误可分为三类，即内容 （material）谬误，措词（verbal）谬误以及形 式（formal）谬误。
However, he is probably best remembered for his creation of the character "Dobie Gillis", who was the subject of a series of short stories compiled under the title, The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis, which became the basis for a CBS television series of the same name, and had previously been the subject of a film, The Affairs of Dobie Gillis (1953). Shulman was also the writer of the series' theme song. The same year that the series began, 1959, a novel continuing the adventures of Dobie and his friends, I Was a Teenage Dwarf, was published. (Its title was a takeoff on what is now seen as a "schlock horror" classic, I Was a Teenage Werewolf, starring Michael Landon.)
love-is-a-fallacy-爱情是谬误
在进入今天主题，讲述我和小美的故事之前我想先给大家推荐这样的一片文章，其实正是因为我自己的经历我才深深的懂得了这篇文章的内在，而我希望将它跟大家分享，如果你在爱情里面遇到类似的问题，那么我相信这篇文章会给你一点启示的，当然同时，你也可以提升自己的英文。
Love Is a Fallacy《爱情是个谬误》这是一篇我非常喜欢的文章，这也是在大学里我教授的三年级外语专业学生高级英语课本里面的一篇经典文章，国外的大学生也会同步在写作课学习这篇文章。
以前我喜欢它只是单纯把它当做一篇幽默的文章来对待，其实也没有深深的去体会过其中滋味，但是现在我才真正体会到为什么爱情是一个谬误。
主人公是一个非常自信甚至很自负的法学院大一男生Dobbie,他自认为又帅，又有才，他看上了自己室友的女友，很想得到那个女生，但是这个女生Polly只是一个表面很漂亮但却很没有脑子的女生，所以Dobbie决定要先改变这个女孩，把她变聪明之后再得到她。
当然第一步是得先得到室友的同意。
室友是一个拜金狂，依然没有脑子，于是Dobbie用一件浣熊大衣作为交换条件就轻松得到了室友的许可，于是就和Polly开始约会了。
约会的内容就是教不同的逻辑谬误给Polly，为的就是让她变聪明，因为主人公认为逻辑是让人变聪明的法宝，于是约会就这么开始了，他教授的逻辑问题如下：1. 绝对判断（Dicto Simpliciter）的谬误。
例子如下：“运动是非常有益的，它能增强体质，所以每个人都应该做运动!”，这个论断是明显错误的，因为运动有益是一种无条件的前提。
比方说，假设你得了心脏病，运动不但无益，反而有害，有不少人医生就不准他们运动。
你必须给这种前提加以限制。
你应该说，一般来说运动是有益的。
或者说，对大多数人是有益的。
否则就是犯了绝对判断的错误2. 草率结论（Hasty Generalization）的谬误。
例子如下：“你不会讲法语，我不会讲法语，皮蒂也不会讲法语。
love is a fallacy的修辞艺术
ove is a fallacy的修辞艺术1. 爱情的虚幻性爱情被认为是一种神圣的情感，但实际上它也有虚幻的一面。
爱情有时会让人感到欢乐，但也可能会让人失望。
爱情可以让人拥有无限的希望，但也可能会让人绝望。
爱情可以让人感受到美好的幸福，但也可能会让人感到无助。
爱情可以让人拥有无尽的力量，但也可能会让人感到无助。
爱情可以让人拥有真实的快乐，但也可能会让人感到空虚。
爱情有时会让人感到安全，但也可能会让人感到不安。
爱情可以让人拥有无尽的美好，但也可能会让人感到痛苦。
爱情可以让人拥有无限的梦想，但也可能会让人感到失望。
爱情可以让人拥有无尽的持久力，但也可能会让人感到空虚。
爱情可以让人拥有无尽的勇气，但也可能会让人感到恐惧。
总而言之，爱情是一种虚幻的情感，它既可以给人带来幸福，也可以给人带来痛苦。
2. 爱情的谬误爱情有时会让人们盲目地追求，以至于忽略了最重要的事情：爱情本身。
人们会把爱情当做一种财富，而不是一种情感，这就是爱情的谬误。
人们会把爱情当做一种工具，用来获得财富和地位，而不是一种温暖的感情。
人们会把爱情当做一种游戏，用来获得胜利，而不是一种真正的情感。
这些谬误使得人们忽略了爱情的真正含义，也使得爱情变得更加脆弱。
3. 爱情的虚假性爱情是一种虚假的情感，它可以让人们感到有安全感，但它也可以让人们陷入痛苦的困境。
爱情可以让人们变得更加自私，甚至可以让人们失去理智。
爱情可以让人们变得更加自私，甚至可以让人们失去理智。
爱情可以让人们变得更加自私，甚至可以让人们失去理智。
爱情可以让人们变得更加自私，甚至可以让人们失去理智。
爱情可以让人们变得更加自私，甚至可以让人们失去理智。
爱情可以让人们变得更加自私，甚至可以让人们失去理智。
爱情可以让人们变得更加自私，甚至可以让人们失去理智。
爱情可以让人们失去理智，从而让人们做出一些他们后悔的事情。
爱情可以让人们放弃自己的价值观，甚至可以让人们变得更加自私。
爱情可以让人们做出一些可能会损害他人的事情，而不去考虑后果。
love is a fallacy爱情是谬误
• 5.Ad Misericordiam (文不对题) • A:What you eat today for breakfast? B:Last night , I ate rice , overnight ate lobster. • 6.False Analogy (错误对比) • The bird‟s nest is made by bird , so the bullpen is also made by cow.
The examples of logical fallacies
• 1.Dicto Simpliciter (以偏概全) • My roommate thinks that philosophy lesson is very hard, so is mine , thus , everyone think that the philosophy lesson is difficult. • 2.Hasty Generalization (草率推断) • Guns and hammer , as well as metal can be recognized as murder tools.But limited purchase of hammers are ridiculous, thus limited to buy guns are also ridiculous.
Charles Lamb (1775-1834) English essayist and critic.
Thomas Carlyle ( 1795-1881) English author, Scottish writer.
John Ruskin (1819-1900) English critic and social theorist. A writer on art and architecture.
love_is_a_fallacy
• When he returned home, Cupid sent by Venus kissed the ivory sculpture on the hand.
• At that time, it was changed to a beautiful woman. A ring was put on her finger. It was Cupid’s ring which made love achieved. Venus granted his wish.
work
Pygmalion(Greek mythology)
Pygmalion was a Cypriot sculptor who carved a woman out of ivory. According to Ovid, after seeing the Propoetides prostituting themselves, he wasn’t interested in women,but his statue was so fair and realistic that he fell in love with it. In the vertex, Venus (Aphrodite)'s festival day came. For the festival, Pygmalion made offerings to Venus and made a wish. "I sincerely wished the ivory sculpture will be changed to a real woman." However, he couldn’t bring himself to express it.
love-is-a-fallacy-爱情是谬误
在进入今天主题，讲述我和小美的故事之前我想先给大家推荐这样的一片文章，其实正是因为我自己的经历我才深深的懂得了这篇文章的内在，而我希望将它跟大家分享，如果你在爱情里面遇到类似的问题，那么我相信这篇文章会给你一点启示的，当然同时，你也可以提升自己的英文。
Love Is a Fallacy《爱情是个谬误》这是一篇我非常喜欢的文章，这也是在大学里我教授的三年级外语专业学生高级英语课本里面的一篇经典文章，国外的大学生也会同步在写作课学习这篇文章。
以前我喜欢它只是单纯把它当做一篇幽默的文章来对待，其实也没有深深的去体会过其中滋味，但是现在我才真正体会到为什么爱情是一个谬误。
主人公是一个非常自信甚至很自负的法学院大一男生Dobbie,他自认为又帅，又有才，他看上了自己室友的女友，很想得到那个女生，但是这个女生Polly 只是一个表面很漂亮但却很没有脑子的女生，所以Dobbie决定要先改变这个女孩，把她变聪明之后再得到她。
当然第一步是得先得到室友的同意。
室友是一个拜金狂，依然没有脑子，于是Dobbie用一件浣熊大衣作为交换条件就轻松得到了室友的许可，于是就和Polly开始约会了。
约会的内容就是教不同的逻辑谬误给Polly，为的就是让她变聪明，因为主人公认为逻辑是让人变聪明的法宝，于是约会就这么开始了，他教授的逻辑问题如下：1. 绝对判断（Dicto Simpliciter）的谬误。
例子如下：“运动是非常有益的，它能增强体质，所以每个人都应该做运动!”，这个论断是明显错误的，因为运动有益是一种无条件的前提。
比方说，假设你得了心脏病，运动不但无益，反而有害，有不少人医生就不准他们运动。
你必须给这种前提加以限制。
你应该说，一般来说运动是有益的。
或者说，对大多数人是有益的。
否则就是犯了绝对判断的错误2. 草率结论（Hasty Generalization）的谬误。
例子如下：“你不会讲法语，我不会讲法语，皮蒂也不会讲法语。
- 1、下载文档前请自行甄别文档内容的完整性，平台不提供额外的编辑、内容补充、找答案等附加服务。
- 2、"仅部分预览"的文档,不可在线预览部分如存在完整性等问题,可反馈申请退款(可完整预览的文档不适用该条件!)。
- 3、如文档侵犯您的权益，请联系客服反馈,我们会尽快为您处理(人工客服工作时间：9:00-18:30)。
4. Simile (My brain was as powerful as a dynamo, as precise as a chemist’s scale, as penetrating as scalpel.)
About the story
The narrator of the story is Dobie Gills, a freshman in a law school who is proud of his logic reasoning and general intellectual capability. Dobie Gills grapples with Petey Bellows, whose girlfriend he hopes that he can persuade to give up and Polly Espy, Petey’s girlfriend he intends to marry after he has improves her. He is quite sure of his final success because he is smarter and it is only logical that the girl will choose him. However, the result is a great surprise to him because the girl turns down his proposal and choose Petey Burch, all because of what Dobie Gills regards as a “silly reason”, thus proving that “Love is a fallacy”.
Rhetorical devices in the story
1. Inversion (Cool was I and logical. // Beautiful she was. Gracious she was. Intelligent she was not. )
2. Metaphor (My brain, that precision instrument, slipped into high gear.)Writing Style
Max Shulman has a good style. The story goes forward at a fast pace with racy dialogues full of American colloquialism and slang. He employs a whole variety of writing techniques to make his story vivid. He use ultra learned terms to reveal the conceit of the narrator and clipped vulgar forms to illustrate Polly Espy’s limited intellectual capability. He also use figurative language profusely and inversion for emphasis. The speed of the narration is maintained by the use of short sentences, elliptical sentences and dashes throughout the story. The combination of all these help to make the story realistic, as one would expect a freshman to talk like that.
Love Is a Fallacy
By Max Shulman
About the author
Max Shulman(1919-1988): one of America’s best-known humorists. Max is a writer of many talents---he has written novels, stories, Broadway plays, movie scenarios, and television scripts. The present text is taken from The Many Loves of Dobie Gills(1951). Dobie Gills, the narrator , is a typical American teen who frequently suffers from romantic angst. The character appeared on a popular televion sitcom during the 1950s and was in a feature film in 1953.
5. Hyperbole (It is not often that one so young has such a giant intellect.)
6. Ellipsis (Same age, same background, but dumb as an ox.)
Rhetorical devices in the story
7. Metonymy (She was, to be sure, a girl who excited the emotions. But I was not one to let my heart rule my head.)